For decades, the answer to a sprained ankle was RICE: rest, ice, compression, elevation. Even the doctor who coined it has since said rest and ice may slow healing. Here is what the research shows now, and what we recommend instead.
“After a sprain, I tell patients to start with light loading, moving through a pain-free range of motion, elevation and compression. Ice is mostly for pain relief, and that relief is temporary. It constricts the blood vessels, which can hold the swelling in place until you get the ankle moving again. Gentle massage helps, and after the first couple of days I prefer warmth to help circulation. Warmth is more comforting, too. But the best thing is movement. As we say at MVP, movement is medicine.”
Dr. Mayur V. Patel, Doctor of Physical Therapy
Where RICE came from, and why it changed
Dr. Gabe Mirkin introduced RICE in 1978, and it became the standard first aid for sprains and strains. PRICE later added Protection, and in 2012 researchers proposed POLICE, replacing complete Rest with Optimal Loading.
In 2015, Mirkin revised his own advice, saying that rest and ice can possibly delay healing.1 The research had been pointing that way for years. A 2004 review of 22 randomized trials found little evidence that ice improves recovery from soft-tissue injuries, and the studies were generally low quality. The review did find marginal evidence that ice works best when it is combined with exercise.2
Movement is medicine
Inflammation is not the enemy. It is the first stage of healing, and tissue needs load to heal strong. Prolonged rest weakens the very tissue you are trying to repair.3
In a randomized trial of about 100 people with ankle sprains, those who started gentle therapeutic exercise in the first week had better ankle function and were more active than those given standard care, with no increase in pain or swelling. Both groups used ice and compression; the difference was early movement.4
A modern recovery timeline
PEACE and LOVE: what replaced RICE
In 2019, physical therapists Blaise Dubois and Jean-Francois Esculier published a new approach in the British Journal of Sports Medicine. It covers the first few days and, just as importantly, the weeks after. Notice what is missing: ice and complete rest.3
Right away
PEACE
- PProtect: limit movement for a few days so it does not get worse.
- EElevate: raise the injured area above your heart.
- AAvoid anti-inflammatories: they may interfere with tissue healing.
- CCompress: use a wrap or tape to limit swelling.
- EEducate: understand what helps and what does not.
After a few days
LOVE
- LLoad: let pain guide a gradual return to normal activity.
- OOptimism: confident, positive expectations are linked to better recovery.
- VVascularisation: pain-free cardio to get blood flowing.
- EExercise: restore motion, strength and balance.
So is ice bad?
Not exactly. Ice is a reasonable way to relieve pain, and short sessions of about 15 to 20 minutes have not been shown to harm human healing.1 What the evidence does not support is icing to make tissue heal faster, or long, repeated icing that keeps you from moving.
After surgery, ice earns its place. A review of seven randomized trials after ACL reconstruction found cold therapy significantly reduced pain, though it did not change swelling drainage or range of motion.5 Follow your surgeon’s protocol in the early post-operative period.
And heat?
At MVP, we usually favor gentle warmth and movement over long icing sessions. Warmth relaxes muscles, eases stiffness and makes it easier to move, which is what drives recovery. For back pain under three months old, a Cochrane review found moderate evidence that heat wraps reduce pain and disability in the short term, with added benefit when combined with exercise. It found too little evidence to judge cold.6
The exception is a fresh, swollen injury. In the first two to three days of a sprain, the few small studies available favor cold over heat, and heat may increase swelling.7 So skip heat on a newly swollen joint, then add warmth before you move once the swelling has settled.
What about massage and Epsom salt baths?
Massage has good support for recovery. A 2018 meta-analysis of 99 studies on recovery after exercise found massage was the most effective technique for reducing muscle soreness and fatigue.8 Gentle massage around a sprain, once the first few days have passed, is a comfortable way to ease stiffness and get things moving.
Epsom salt baths are worth it for the warm soak. The idea is that magnesium from the salt soaks in through the skin, but a 2017 scientific review found no good evidence that this happens and concluded that skin absorption of magnesium is not yet proven.9 The warm water itself can still relax muscles and ease stiffness. If you enjoy Epsom salt baths, there is no harm in them once swelling has settled. Just know that the warmth is likely doing the work.
When to get it checked
- You cannot take four steps on it, or cannot bear weight at all.
- There is pain directly on the bone, an obvious deformity or a loud pop with immediate swelling.
- Numbness, tingling, or a foot or hand that is pale or cold.
- It is not clearly better after a week, or keeps giving way.
Severe pain, deformity or loss of feeling needs urgent care. For everything else, no referral is needed to see a Doctor of Physical Therapy.
The bottom line
- Even the creator of RICE has revised it: complete rest and routine icing may slow healing.
- Protect, elevate and compress for the first few days, then start moving as pain allows.
- Ice is fine for short-term pain relief and after surgery, not as a way to speed healing.
- Skip heat on fresh swelling; after that, warmth, gentle massage and movement are good choices.
- Movement is medicine.
This article is for general education and is not medical advice. After surgery, follow your surgeon’s instructions.
References
- Yale Medicine. Should you use the RICE protocol for injuries? Includes Dr. Gabe Mirkin’s 2015 revision of the RICE advice he introduced in The Sports Medicine Book, 1978. Source
- Bleakley C, McDonough S, MacAuley D. The use of ice in the treatment of acute soft-tissue injury: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2004. Source
- Dubois B, Esculier JF. Soft-tissue injuries simply need PEACE and LOVE. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2020. Source
- Bleakley CM, et al. Effect of accelerated rehabilitation on function after ankle sprain: randomised controlled trial. BMJ, 2010. Source
- Raynor MC, et al. Cryotherapy after ACL reconstruction: a meta-analysis. Journal of Knee Surgery, 2005. Source
- French SD, et al. Superficial heat or cold for low back pain. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2006. Source
- Clinical Inquiries. Heat or ice for acute ankle sprain? Journal of Family Practice. Source
- Dupuy O, et al. An evidence-based approach for choosing post-exercise recovery techniques to reduce markers of muscle damage, soreness, fatigue, and inflammation: a systematic review with meta-analysis. Frontiers in Physiology, 2018. Source
- Gröber U, Werner T, Vormann J, Kisters K. Myth or reality: transdermal magnesium? Nutrients, 2017. Source
